Not all "Expanders" Are Created Equal. Here's Why...
Rethinking Orthodontic Treatment: A Critical Evaluation of Common "Expansion" Appliances (Most "Tip")
As an orthodontist with extensive experience, having observed over 25,000 mouths and treated more than 5,000 patients, I've developed a nuanced understanding of the efficacy of various orthodontic appliances. My observations, particularly regarding maxillary expansion, TMJ health, and airway issues, paint a picture that challenges some conventional orthodontic practices.
Understanding the Limitations of Popular Orthodontic Appliances:
- Questioning the Efficacy of ALF, Myobrace, HealthyStart, and Others: Despite their popularity, appliances like the ALF, Myobrace, HealthyStart, banded RPEs, Quad Helix, and W-arch often fall short in terms of effective maxillary expansion. The dearth of peer-reviewed evidence supporting their ability to consistently translate bone or expand like a bonded RPE is telling. In contrast, the bonded RPE, maintained for six months or longer, not only facilitates effective expansion but also serves as a TMJ deprogrammer, aiding in the healing of TMJ disorders.
- The Deceptive Nature of Tipping Appliances: Many orthodontic appliances, including clear aligners, primarily result in the tipping of teeth rather than true bodily movement. This approach can lead to relapse, anterior crowding, or a resurgence of overbites. The body's rejection of this unnatural positioning of posterior teeth underscores the limitations of these methods. In contrast, traditional braces are more effective in achieving the desired bodily translation through bone.
- Long-term Stability and Health Over Quick Fixes: The distinction between tipping and true expansion is crucial. Tipping compromises the longevity of treatment outcomes and can lead to further complications. In contrast, treatments that ensure bodily movement and stability, such as traditional braces or properly used bonded RPEs, offer sustainable solutions that align with the goals of orthodontic intervention.
Concluding Thoughts: Advocating for Evidence-Based, Holistic Approaches.
In conclusion, the journey towards effective and sustainable orthodontic treatment is not solely about aesthetic improvement but also about long-term oral health and stability. The orthodontic community must embrace a more critical and evidence-based approach, moving away from appliances that offer superficial, temporary fixes through tipping, and towards those that provide comprehensive, biomechanically sound solutions.
As practitioners, it is our responsibility to not only correct dental misalignments but also consider the broader implications on TMJ health and airway functionality. By doing so, we can ensure that our interventions are not just effective in the short term but also beneficial for our patients' long-term oral and overall health.
If you or someone you know want a straighter smile and all the benefits that come with it, you can contact HeRo Orthodontics. They can help you achieve a healthy and vibrant smile for the whole family. Just give them a call at (972) 722-4376.
Be a HeRo share a smile!
Contact Us







